A Meeting of Minds - An Anne McCaffrey Discussion Forum

A Meeting of Minds - An Anne McCaffrey Discussion Forum (http://forums.srellim.org/index.php)
-   Petaybee and Acorna (http://forums.srellim.org/forumdisplay.php?f=10)
-   -   Acorna books (http://forums.srellim.org/showthread.php?t=7302)

Golden Talisath Jan 6 2010 06:23 AM

Acorna books
 
Hi, I have a question regarding the list of Acorna books listed by Cheryl. I have almost the complete set, but she wrote that the first title is Acorna (with Margaret Ball), and than it writes *The Unicorn Girl (Jody Lynn Nye et al.; *not authored by McCaffrey). Ok, I have the Unicorn girl, but is that the same as Acorna?

Cheryl Jan 6 2010 09:00 AM

Re: Acorna books
 
The Unicorn Girl is a book of short stories relating to Acorna, yes.

P'ter Jan 6 2010 05:21 PM

Re: Acorna books
 
I regard that volume as the only "official" fan-fic Anne's allowed.

Brenda Jan 6 2010 08:17 PM

Re: Acorna books
 
To clarify - Acorna is NOT the same book as The Unicorn Girl.

Cheryl Jan 6 2010 09:09 PM

Re: Acorna books
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by P'ter (Post 157541)
I regard that volume as the only "official" fan-fic Anne's allowed.

Then you're forgetting the two Crossroads books by JL Nye!

P'ter Jan 7 2010 02:53 AM

Re: Acorna books
 
:blush: :O :blush: :O: But then I've only got one of them

Golden Talisath Jan 7 2010 11:12 AM

Re: Acorna books
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Brenda (Post 157549)
To clarify - Acorna is NOT the same book as The Unicorn Girl.

Sooo… is it necessary for me to read Acorna, or can I just read the Unicorn Girl and continue with the series?

Brenda Jan 7 2010 11:28 AM

Re: Acorna books
 
Quote:

...can I just read the Unicorn Girl and continue with the series?
No. I did that and was very, very confused! If you are new to the series, you should read Acorna first. The short stories in The Unicorn Girl make very little sense if you haven't read the first book!

Golden Talisath Jan 7 2010 02:35 PM

Re: Acorna books
 
Ok, thank you all.

eann Jan 10 2010 02:54 AM

Re: Acorna books
 
I was invited to submit a story for The Unicorn Girl but had a lot of other things on my plate at the time. It was a theme anthology based on the Acorna concept. The whole idea behind Acorna originally was that it was supposed to be an inspiration for multi-media work, the concept could have been turned into a cartoon show, graphic novel, all sorts of unexploited possibilities. Alas, it never did.
But the stories in Unicorn girl were paid for so I don't think they really qualify as fan fic. And Jody Lyn's books weren't really fan fic either--they were under contract to Tor and anyway, Jody Lyn may be a fan of Annie's (as am I) but she's also a collaborator and a professional author and editor. There's another important part to this in that Annie gets a share of the proceeds of all of this work. It isn't something done independently of her that she rubber stamped afterward--there was an agreement and a pre-existing contract, and she got compensated, as is only fair, for use of her intellectual property and her name.
BTW, Punkin's real name wasn't actually Pumpkin or Punkin. I was just reminded that as a registered Maine Coon purebred cat, he had a very fancy name but he did look more like a Punkin (pumpkin). That's him Annie is cuddling in the author picture on the inside flap of the jacket of Catalyst.

eann Jan 10 2010 03:01 AM

Re: Acorna books
 
The first two Acorna novels are Acorna, then Acorna's Quest by Anne and Margaret Ball.
Followed by the five with Annie and me. 3. Acorna's People 4. Acorna's World 5. Acorna's Search 6. Acrona's Rebels (lots of cats in this one) and 7. Acorna's Triumph. Then there are three in the Acorna's Children series 1. First Warning 2. Second Watch 3. Third Wave
that are continuations of the original series featuring Acorna's daughters and android foster son. For more about these series including synopsis and US cover art, see the page on my website http://www.eascarborough.com/books/acorna.htm

Brenda Jan 10 2010 09:56 PM

Re: Acorna books
 
I assume that "The Unicorn Girl" goes between the first two novels?

eann Jan 11 2010 02:22 AM

Re: Acorna books
 
No, it's independent of the main storyline, set in the world but not part of the series.

Brenda Jan 11 2010 10:23 AM

Re: Acorna books
 
But some things, like that character - whatsher name, the Baron's daughter - doesn't she show up again in one of the other books?

Hans Jan 11 2010 04:40 PM

Re: Acorna books
 
Eann, I have to disagree with you. I don't think you can see The Unicorn Girl as (totally) seperate from the story line of the (early) Acorna books. You probably mean that is itsn't a art of the series as a whole? I suppose, especially with the information you gave, it's logical that's it's not an integral part of the series and the plots of the tories are not needed for the series' books, but you can't see the stories seperate from the series as they have the same characters and especially a story like Mickey Zucker Reichert's "Trouble in Kezedet" loans heavily from the original series.
If you see Acorna's search for her people and subsequently for her love as the "main storyline", then you are, of course, eminently correct. To my feeling the stories are part of the series, but I'd be interested to hear what others say/think or if I misunderstood you somewhat. :)

And oh, I think it's an absolutely shame that life cheated you out of contributing a story to that book!

eann Jan 12 2010 01:02 AM

Re: Acorna books
 
Life didn't cheat me out of contributing a story to the book, Hans. I declined because I was busy with other projects. Good grief, man, I wrote 8 books in that series, which is more Acorna than most people. Drawing on the same world is not the same thing as being part of the storyline though. Even if you use some of the same characters. There have been several, if not many, anthologies that do that.
Actually, I edited something similar for my Channeling Cleopatra and Cleopatra 7.2 books. There was an anthology, Past Lives Present Tense, first where I invited other authors to play with the same idea--and a few of the central characters. As in the solicitation for the Unicorn Girl, the boundaries were outlined so that while a short story seemed to be happening within the same world and time, it would not inhibit me (or in the case of Unicorn Girl, Margaret, Anne or much later, me) in developing situations and characters. My own story was a prequel to the other two books and they referred back to it, alluding to some of the characters in it. Several of the other stories also mentioned these characters but their stories were independent of mine and of the rest of the book. The relationship was that they used the same central idea. I don't know if I still have it, but the last time I rooted through my files I did see the solicitation to participate in The Unicorn Girl and it was pretty detailed about what could and could not be used by those contributing stories. That was one reason I declined. I was juggling two novels and editing another one and didn't have time for the complexity of shoe-horning in a story of my own in another milieu.

Hans Jan 12 2010 02:57 AM

Re: Acorna books
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by eann (Post 157888)
<snip>I don't know if I still have it, but the last time I rooted through my files I did see the solicitation to participate in The Unicorn Girl and it was pretty detailed about what could and could not be used by those contributing stories. That was one reason I declined. I was juggling two novels and editing another one and didn't have time for the complexity of shoe-horning in a story of my own in another milieu.

That's pretty interesting and another reason that it is really great to have real authors here on MoM :heart:

OK, not 'cheated' by life than, but by hard work. I'm sure you don't mind me wanting a short story by your hand in there. :)

Side question: to which (who'se) world wouldn't you mind contributing a story? :sly:

eann Jan 12 2010 04:28 AM

Re: Acorna books
 
Oh, I've done scads and scads of short stories for various theme anthologies--the only one I recall as being set in another author's world though was one I wrote for Andre Norton for a Witch World antho. It might have been my very first short story.
I'd have done one for Acorna or any of the other of Anne's worlds if I had had the time. But often the deadlines are rather quick on these things. The antho I most enjoyed working on was the one Annie and I edited together called Space Opera. We got some really wonderful stories for that--Spider Robinson's and Gene Wolfe's still stand out in my mind. But that wasn't set in a particular world. It would be very challenging to do something for any of the large and intricate constructs of some authors but I wouldn't mind trying one for Terry Pratchett's Disc (or is it with a "k"?) World should the opportunity arise. Only if I got to play with some of his characters. I'm just now listening to the Wee Free Men series on audio books and it's still a joy. I also like Johnny and the Dead (and the Bomb and there was one other one) and the Amazing Maurice and His Educated Rodents.

GinnyStar Jan 21 2010 01:37 AM

Re: Acorna books
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by eann (Post 157746)
The first two Acorna novels are Acorna, then Acorna's Quest by Anne and Margaret Ball.
Followed by the five with Annie and me. 3. Acorna's People 4. Acorna's World 5. Acorna's Search 6. Acrona's Rebels (lots of cats in this one) and 7. Acorna's Triumph. Then there are three in the Acorna's Children series 1. First Warning 2. Second Watch 3. Third Wave
that are continuations of the original series featuring Acorna's daughters and android foster son. For more about these series including synopsis and US cover art, see the page on my website http://www.eascarborough.com/books/acorna.htm

6. Acrona's Rebels (lots of cats in this one) Why I love it :) thanks I' don have 2,3,4 of the books, and I bet the reader for the National Libary Services for the Blind and Physicallly Handicapped had a hard time with some of the worlds, glad they had the Glossary in the front of book on tape then the back or folk wouldn't have understand it.

GinnyStar Jan 21 2010 01:45 AM

Re: Acorna books
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Brenda (Post 157831)
But some things, like that character - whatsher name, the Baron's daughter - doesn't she show up again in one of the other books?

Yes she dose which one I don't recall its the one where John Becker and RK find Aair and Mac is pick up by him, which I wouldn't have a clue.

eann Jan 24 2010 05:52 AM

Re: Acorna books
 
Becker and RK are my characters and the Baron's daughter appeared in one of the books with them--so that wasn't in Unicorn Girl. I made up those characters after Unicorn Girl was published. (Becker and RK, not the Baron's daughter)

GinnyStar Jan 24 2010 04:07 PM

Re: Acorna books
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Brenda (Post 157831)
But some things, like that character - whatsher name, the Baron's daughter - doesn't she show up again in one of the other books?

Its in ACORNA'S PEOPLE thank to eann site. Its one I don't have :O

eann Jan 25 2010 07:49 PM

Re: Acorna books
 
Oh, and it's Jonas P. Becker, not John. Becker Sr. was Theophilus Becker.

Raphy Nov 4 2011 06:30 AM

Re: Acorna books
 
I've read all of the Acorna and Acornas children books and I loved them. I was very disappointed when I found out the the series was finished. I'm thirsty for more!!! Will there be anymore I wonder?

(May I be cheeky and say what a surprise and pleasure it is to find one of my favourite co-authors here? Eann I absolutely love Jonas and RK!!!!) :blush:

mawra Dec 31 2011 07:09 PM

Re: Acorna books
 
My S.S. on KT gave me Acorna. Must have rest of Acorna books.

kindan Jan 3 2012 12:04 PM

Re: Acorna books
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mawra (Post 181480)
My S.S. on KT gave me Acorna. Must have rest of Acorna books.

Awesome. Let me know when you get to the 2nd book and I'll read it along with you :)

Leprechaun Sep 21 2017 08:54 PM

Re: Acorna books
 
Can any-one tell me where Anne got the idea to write the Acorna series?


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 09:23 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2018, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.

A Meeting of Minds forum owned by Cheryl B. Miller.
All references to worlds and characters based on Anne McCaffrey’s fiction are copyright © Anne McCaffrey 1967-2008, all rights reserved, and used by permission of the author.